Moment of Truth

For those who’ve never seen Fox’s execrable game show, Moment of Truth, it goes like this: the contestant, who’s hooked up to a polygraph machine, is asked a series of embarrassing questions. The more honest the answers, the more money the contestant wins.

Check out this abridged version of an episode featuring Aaron Dunbar, an Emergency Medical Technician. Two of the questions — asked by an actual fat person, presumably to increase Aaron’s discomfort in answering — are “Do you think fat people are simply weak?” and “Are you repulsed by fat people?” Aaron’s answer to both is “Yes,” followed by the robotic female voice representing the polygraph: “True.”

This might be the man who shows up to save your life in an emergency — a man who is repulsed by fat people and believes they are weak. And he’s not alone. I’ve personally had a conversation with an EMT who expressed similar sentiments — having to help very fat people was disgusting to him, and he found himself feeling anger toward them for “letting themselves get that way.” A 2001 study by Kelly Brownell and Rebecca Puhl found that 24% of nurses admit to being “repulsed” by fat patients. Last summer, paramedics in Gloucester, England, joked as a 245-pound woman died in her home, because they couldn’t figure out how to move her to the hospital.

For all the empty talk about being concerned for our health, there sure are a lot of medical professionals out there who simply don’t want to do their jobs when it comes to fat patients.

(Via Shakesville.)

Leave a comment


  1. Cindy

     /  June 25, 2008

    Every time I read these reports, I’m less inclined to seek medical care.

  2. Janell

     /  June 25, 2008

    Is this really the right video clip?

  3. Lisa

     /  June 25, 2008

    What we in the fat community face here, is a job to do! We have to work hard to educate people- that we are human and deserving of consideration. I know it sucks that some people don’t already realize this, but that’s the reality and it must be altered to a better one. I also believe people who don’t share this attitude in their work should be acknowledged, praised, shown as an example of real humanity. We need to praise the good attitudes that people have too.

  4. AnnieMcPhee

     /  June 25, 2008

    That link to the 245 lb woman and the paramedics is *insane.* I was apparently pretty full of fluid when I had to be brought to the hospital, weighed a good 280, and it took about 5 minutes to get me onto the stretcher and into the ambulance. AND it was a hella cramped and awkward space they had to get me out of. That really really pisses me off.

    As to the show – ugh. I saw the ads and said “Now that looks horrible.” Anyway, an instant polygraph? What is this, Star Trek? Not that polygraph is reliable anyway, but an instant reading? It doesn’t work like that, at least not to my knowledge.

  5. AnnieMcPhee

     /  June 25, 2008

    Fwiw, that video is of “So You Think You Can Dance” and not “Moment of Truth.” I’d like to see the MOT clip🙂

  6. Sarah

     /  June 26, 2008

    I don’t understand WHY these individuals get into health care if they are not willing to serve the public.

  7. LeslieR

     /  June 26, 2008

    Yeah, I also saw a clip for “So You Think You Can Dance”, not sure why. Also to Annie, I watched the one of the first episodes of the show and I’m pretty sure they’re not claiming it as an instant polygraph. I think they ask the contestant a whole lot of questions before the show while hooked up to a polygraph and determine whether or not they were telling the truth (as much as a polygraph can, I guess). Then they ask select questions during the show (probably the ones with the most titillating results) and when he answers, they just say whether or not his answer agreed with their earlier assessment of the truth. So they’re not claiming an instant polygraph. Either way, I don’t find it a very interesting show.

    About the topic in general, I find it very sad. In the last year I’ve weighed anywhere between 215-300 pounds and when I interact with people, particularly medical staff, I attempt not to feel badly in large part by reassuring myself of their professionalism. I know despite the fact that these people are in health care, they are human, are not perfect and will therefore make mistakes. But it’s still very sad to me to realize that you can’t always rely on someone’s professionalism, discretion, or common decency.

  8. O.C.

     /  June 26, 2008

    How long will it take for people to realize that a significant portion of the health risks supposedly attributable to size are actually coming from the significantly, measurably poorer health care large people receive? Every story like this just angers me more.

  9. Sarah:

    Two things. First, many aspiring health care professionals see fat as the problem that needs to be fixed, and who better to come save the day than Teh Haters? Second, the system pretty much forces non-fat-haters to engage in fat-hating behaviors—pushing whatever weight-loss products are available—or else they’re accused of “not practicing evidence-based medicine.”

    And, word, OC.

  10. Zen

     /  June 27, 2008

    Wow. That guy is um. A piece of work.

    I refuse to watch that show, simply because of the commercials I’ve seen for it. It’s horrible.

  11. justme

     /  June 28, 2008

    Unfortunately no surprise here.
    Not with the big revelation or the fact that network television feels this qualifies as entertainment.

  12. Laura

     /  June 28, 2008

    It also does not help when former fat women get on CNN and tell the world that the humiliation of a child asking why she is so fat led to her losing weight. This gives permission to everyone, including medical professionals, to humiliate fat people in hopes that it will cause them to lose weight.

  13. Christina

     /  August 1, 2008

    This paramedic needs to give up his license. He should not be practicing if he cannot devote the same level of care to all his patients. I would not hire him. If he is repulsed by a fat person, I believe he will not do what is necessary to help that patient.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  • First Do No Harm

  • Categories

  • Recent Posts

  • RSS Notes from the Fatosphere

    • Fake Allies: Time to Play Dirty! December 7, 2016
      I just want to put my head in my hands. I value civility. I value extending the olive branch and hearing different ideas. But I also value being blunt, being effective, setting boundaries, breaking out of the echo chamber. Well, guess what? I’m just about out of olive branches. I’m about ready to play dirty […]via Dead of Winter (Notes From The Fatosphere)
    • Trump Appointee Wouldn’t Hire Fat People December 6, 2016
      Delos “Toby” Cosgrove, CEO of the Cleveland Clinic, was recently selected by Trump to join an advisory committee that, according to a news release by the administration”brings together CEOs and business leaders who know what it takes to create jobs and drive economic growth. My administration is committed to drawing on private sector expertise and cutting th […] (Notes From The Fatosphere)
    • Dieters Gain More Weight in Pregnancy December 5, 2016
      Care providers often push "obese" women to lose weight before pregnancy in hopes that weight loss will reduce complications and make for a healthier pregnancy.However, one consequence they often fail to consider is that the woman who loses weight before pregnancy often gains excessively during pregnancy.This is logical; the body thinks it is starvi […] (Notes From The Fatosphere)
    • We’re Fat People, Not Metaphors December 5, 2016
      One of the ways that weight-based bigotry is perpetuated is the use of fat people and being fat as metaphor.  Recently reader Jen commented about a situation where this was happening to her and gave me permission to blog about it.I am the only fat person, in a group of 14 people, for whom issues like alcoholism, drug abuse and domestic partner violence seem […] (Notes From The Fatosphere)
    • Words Matter December 5, 2016
      “Sticks and stones can break my bones, but words can never hurt me” is a lie. To someone who’s being bullied verbally, as long as the bullying never crosses that line, it can be a helpful lie. You tell yourself words can’t hurt you, and reinforce that you aren’t defined by the bully’s opinion of you.  You don’t let their poison into your heart, and because y […] (Notes From The Fatosphere)
    • On Fatlicious Holiday Gift Giving 2016 December 5, 2016
      ‘Tis the season to spoil those you love, and yourself, with some fatlicious gifts. Here is my guide to fatlicious shopping for the 2016 holiday season. Treat yourself and those you love, and support fat people!  For the fatshionistaFat necklace from Fancy Lady Industries Alexa Jumper from Copper Union Queen Cartwheels Choker from Chubby Cartwheels   For the […] (Notes From The Fatosphere)
    • Fatphobia Claims Another Life December 2, 2016
      Today’s blog is pretty intense – content warning for discussion of bullying, harassment, and suicide.Brandy Vela sent her sister Jackie a text that said “”I love you so much, please remember that, and I’m sorry for everything.” Then she took her own life.Brandy was the victim of cyberbullying.  According to Jackie:“People would make up fake Facebook accounts […] (Notes From The Fatosphere)
    • Underpants Rule November 30, 2016
      This is one of those annual tradition posts – it’s the Underpants Rule and it is pretty simple: when it comes to personal choices, everyone is the boss of their own underpants. So, when it comes to personal choices, you get to choose for you and other people get to choose from them and it’s not your job to tell other people what to do and it’s not their job […] (Notes From The Fatosphere)
    • Corrections to E’s Story November 29, 2016
      I have to make a couple of corrections to this post from two months ago. First, C wasn’t sick for decades; it was several years, but not decades.The second correction is a pleasant surprise: E is doing better. She’s regained some weight, she has a better attitude toward food, and she seems generally more positive. She’s still lost some memory and some mental […] (Notes From The Fatosphere)
    • External Version for Breech After Prior Cesarean November 29, 2016
      An External Cephalic Version (ECV, or turning the baby manually to a head-down position) is one option open to people whose babies are breech. However, if you have had a prior cesarean, you may be told that this is not an option for you.The evidence does not support excluding those with a prior cesarean from an External Cephalic Version. It's time for o […] (Notes From The Fatosphere)
%d bloggers like this: